March 5, 2014

What Ruby Eats: A Kibblecopia


What do you feed your dog? Once upon a time, most family pets ate Pedigree from the grocery store - I still remember the yellow bags with the blue ribbon.  This question seems to be a hot topic these days and one that can quickly turn into a heated debate.  Raw vs. Kibble, Homemade vs. Store-bought, Big Brands vs. Small Batch... the battles are as numerous as the options. I've been meaning to talk for some time about what Ruby eats, and it's a subject that loosely fits into this week's fostering theme since any foster of mine will be eating the same thing. As you will see, this is a little bit of everything!

It wasn't terribly long ago that my dogs ate Purina Beneful, according to some sources one of the very worst.  I was on a just-out-of-college budget and we all had to make do with less than high-quality cuisine.  As my canine knowledge grew and my means increased, I started switching to what I viewed as better brands such as Merrick and Blue Buffalo.  My Chow mix, Lasya, developed a lot of health issues as she aged and she was placed on a "prescription diet," by our old veterinarian, something I now have a more skeptical view of.  These dog foods, while designed for management of particular illnesses, are often made with a lot of undesirable and filler ingredients, such as corn, that many of us steer clear of in feeding our dogs.  For instance, the Hill's K/D dry that Lasya was eating for a while contains as its only meat ingredients (none of which come first) pork fat and chicken liver flavor.  I discussed switching her to something I felt better about with my local pet food store, Kriser's, and they helped me find a kibble with a similar nutritional profile and better ingredients.

I again turned to Kriser's when I adopted Ruby, knowing that I wanted her to be on a high quality canned and kibble diet.  I feed canned food for breakfast and kibble at night, often doled out for Relaxation Protocol sessions or trick training or procured from one of her treat-dispensing puzzle toys. We started with Nature's Variety Instinct, a grain-free kibble which receives a 5-star rating on Dog Food Advisor, and Weruva canned entrees, another 5-star earner.  Ruby seemed to like all of these but occasionally would lose interest at mealtime.  I picked up a can of Fromm Four Star Nutritionals Shredded Beef for her (rated 4-star on Dog Food Advisor and included on the Whole Dog Journal's Approved Dry Food List of 2013) and she readily cleaned her plate at breakfast time day after day.  This is now our first canned choice.

After some communication with Fromm Family Foods, they sent over a generous box of kibble samples for us in their wide variety of flavors as well as a full-sized bag of their Duck and Sweet Potato Recipe.  Ruby found all the flavors to her liking except the Salmon a la Veg, and seemed particularly fond of the Whitefish & Potato and Pork & Applesauce (neither of which are grain-free).  Overall I am really pleased with the Fromm brand - they offer quality ingredients and a large selection of flavors that should satisfy the pickiest of eaters as well as address most food allergies. 

I am very fortunate that Ruby does not appear to have any food allergies or sensitivities, and for this reason as well as her enthusiasm for dinner-time diversity, I've decided to maintain her on a rotation diet using several of the afore-mentioned brands that I like and trust.  I'll be rotating her kibble on a bag-to-bag basis between Nature's Variety and Fromm, and cans between Weruva, Fromm and Merrick.  This will also allow us to continue food reviews if the product is something that meets my standards. I certainly don't want to eat the same thing constantly, why should Ruby?

When we travel, I've found Stella & Chewy's Freeze Dried Patties to be a really convenient food on-the-go.  They come in resealable pouches which are a cinch to pack. Ruby especially likes the Duck Duck Goose flavor so it's a special treat as well as being easy to re-hydrate.

Eating our veggies
 
I will often share tidbits of my dinner with Ruby, she just has to be reminded "don't be rude" and will usually settle down next to me and wait for her morsels of carrot, broccoli, or the occasional salt-and-vinegar potato chip (initially given in hopes of having a moment like this, but instead, she loved it!).  I supplement her diet with coconut oil and she gets a ridiculous assortment of treats from the many subscription boxes that I order. 

I am happy that I have the luxury of putting so much thought and effort into what Ruby eats, and that the research trends and demands of the dog-loving public are making honesty, quality and safety top priorities.  Our dogs would gladly eat many horrifying things that aren't on even the worst brands' ingredient list, and they are lucky they have us looking out for their tummies and long-term health!  Whatever you feed your dog, I have no doubt that like me, you do it with love and purpose, and that every bowl is met with a wagging tail.


DISCLAIMERI received an assortment of dry dog foods from Fromm Family Foods in exchange for my honest review.

9 comments:

  1. It really is amazing how far dog food has come. I'm so grateful that there are better options available to those of us that can afford them. With my first dog Shadow - I gave her I think Iams or Purina. Then discovered she had a LOT of different food allergies. At that point, I found I was forced to educate myself on what is in dog food and I was pretty shocked and a little grossed out. I also ended up having to learn how to bake dog treats as she was allergic to about 98% of the dog treats offered at that time.

    So now, even though Blueberry doesn't seem to have any serious food allergies (although she does do better with lamb, beef, or bison as poultry and fish based foods seem to make her stools a bit soft), I give her a high quality food. To break up the monotony of it - I switch from the same brand, but different meat every month or so. I also add either a hard boiled egg or boiled beef or lamb stew meat to her food in the evenings. I'm right there with you on the fact that I certainly would get bored eating the same thing every single day - so I feel like B appreciates a little variety as well.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This is a thoughtful discussion of a contentious topic! I think everyone has to find what's the right food at the intersection of their dog's needs and their budget. We struggled to find a food that would suit Cooper's protein allergies and Emmett's need for grain-free, so we had settled on Wellness Core Ocean, which was great. Then I started reading about rotation diets, and... very long process short... we now have three solid options in rotation with a fourth (hopefully) coming soon. It's very difficult to find the right fits for this mixed bunch, but I'm really happy that we're on the right path. Thanks for tackling this and sharing your process!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Multiple dogs add more complexity to the challenge. With my previous two dogs, I had one underweight picky eater with the early stages of kidney disease, and one plump, healthy indiscriminate eater. At times they were eating different meals entirely. Do you have any other good information sources for the rotation diet? It makes intuitive sense to me but I haven't found many articles about it.

      Delete
  3. This sounds a lot like what I would be feeding if I did/could do more commercial food with Silas. I actually feed him some Fromm Pork and Peas (not the other pork one, which, IIRC, has some chicken), mostly as cheap-and-easy training treats. Silas *loves* the Fromm canned foods, but weirdly I can't find them around here. Fromm is, for the record, the ONLY prepared pork food that existed last time I checked. (I don't know how you finagled a sample from them, let alone a generous one. I got a coupon when I asked.)

    I also love the Stella and Chewy's freeze dried. If I had a toy-breed, that's all I would feed, but even Silas is too big to eat a food that expensive. For a while they really miffed me with their mixed proteins, but their new flavors are all allergy-friendly.

    The other prepared food that we use regularly is the Honest Kitchen.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Fromm liked the Chewy.com review I did of their treats a while back and offered to send the food samples! I utilize Twitter and Instagram to promote any brand mentions or photos and it definitely has its benefits!

      So true about the cost of the S&C's - that would be astronomical to feed exclusively.

      Delete
  4. I agonised over what to feed Vulpe for a long time. I'm vegan, so it's been super hard to reconcile my own values with healthy food, produced with animal welfare in mind - a conundrum!

    These days I mostly feed her cooked fish with brown rice and vegetables (usually whatever I get in my weekly veg box). She loves mackerel and salmon, but gets chicken occasionally too. When she was much younger my ex-partner used to buy and cook all sorts of meat for her every day, so she turns her nose up at even the highest quality kibble these days :/

    I'm glad people are becoming more aware though. There was a documentary over here in the UK not long ago about the 'truth' behind most pet foods. Shocking stuff :/

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm a mostly-vegetarian myself (seafood at restaurants occasionally) and I've had to get over my squeamishness about handling meat products, especially with feeding some freeze-dried raw.

      It's so nice that you cook for Vulpe - I think that is ideal! Ruby is odd about salmon dog food, but she does like the Whitefish kibble.

      Delete
  5. Since becoming involved in dog blogging and learning more about the ingredients in dog food (Thanks Slimdoggy) I have tried switching from Iams to explore different brands. I am currently feeding Bentley Petbrosia and he is loving it! Thanks for the info!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's great! It's all about being educated and making the best choice for your dog within your means.

      Delete

Thanks so much for visiting The Ginger Sisters at Rubicon Days! We enjoy each and every comment and love getting to know our readers.